The Pixel Hive
gallery blog home
 
linksaboutwrapit ?>
 
Plagiarism? - gallery update
 
Some of you will have no doubt seen the Bears3 characters created by Matt Everitt and myself. If not check them out here http://www.veoh.com/channels/Bears3

Bears3 are characters we created which were animated to dialogue taken from Ricky Gervais's Xfm radio show. They are featured on Ricky's website and on the Xfm site.

The Bears have been very popular over the past couple of years, featuring in Pictoplasma's Characters in Motion book and on the accompanying DVD. They also toured the world as part of the Onedotzero Film Festival, and more recently appeared on BBC1 (see below)

It recently came to our attention that there are television advertisements for the Irish Lotto featuring some familiar characters.... but don't take our word for it, let us know what you think:


See the Lotto vids here

The agency involved in the ads are DDFH&B, and the production company are Brown Bag Films.

Discussion on the Creative Ireland forums started by suggesting that perhaps we may have ripped off the Lotto ads. Things are soon cleared up when people defend us by stating the Bears were around long before the lotto ads. People involved in the pitching of the ads have said that Bears3 were being shown during the development and used as reference.

http://www.creativeireland.com/forums/showthread.php?t=3347

Unfortunately Brown Bag Film's solicitors weren't happy about this, and demanded no further discussion of this sort:

"For legal reasons I would ask that Creative Ireland members post no more topics in relation to this issue, or Brown Bag Films.

Solicitors acting on behalf of Brown Bag Films are currently in contact with Creative Ireland.

Creative Ireland takes any issue of defamation very seriously and our moderators and myself act as swiftly as possible to deal with any such issues that may arise once contacted."

Naturally the folk at Creative Ireland aren't too happy about being silenced like this. This has lead to a few spin off threads where no names are mentioned, but it's clear what is being discussed. It also moved people to email us with some helpful information.


UPDATE:
Further Discussion here, on the amusingly titled "Youthoughtwewouldntnotice.com", a site dedicated to those who rip off others:
http://youthoughtwewouldntnotice.com/blog3/?p=197


UPDATE:
Things summarised nicely on Wowblog:
http://www.wowblog.co.uk/?p=430

UPDATE:
The story is featured on page 3 of todays (31/1/07) Irish Metro:



UPDATE:
Stash is a monthly DVD showcase of animation, VFX and motion graphics for advertising and broadcast. Issue 26 featured the Irish Lottery Ads promimently, so it's good to see them picking up the story on their feed here:
http://feed.stashmedia.tv/feed/2007/1/31/you-stole-my-homage.html

UPDATE:

Got a mention on the 3DsMax news site Maxunderground:
http://maxunderground.com/archives/003484_look_familiar.html

UPDATE:
Hello Pilkipedian's... thanks for the support:
http://www.pilkipedia.co.uk/forum/viewtopic.php?t=1974

UPDATE:
Blogorrah pick up the story:
http://blogorrah.com/reanimated-or-not-you-decide.html

UPDATE:
Skangerland pick up the story:
http://skangerland.blogspot.com/search/label/Creative%20Ireland

UPDATE:
Got a mention on James Henrys Blog:
http://jamesandthebluecat.blogspot.com/

UPDATE:
The Bears were on BBC1 last night as part of the Comedy Connections programme. Click the image below for the clip.






UPDATE:
Ireland's answer to Private Eye magazine, 'The Phoenix', has run this article:






UPDATE:
11/03/07
Got featured in the Sunday Times, click image for full article:






UPDATE:

Paddy Power bookies have favourable odds on the Lotto Ads "disallowed to air on RTE in 2007 due to legal action against the creators"




UPDATE:
See what the folks over at Cartoon Brew have to say:
http://www.cartoonbrew.com/advertising/animation-plagiarism
work by matt, site by drew
new media